Monday, December 20, 2010

Who's the Biggest Terrorist? Yo' Mama!

Dec. 21 PM Update: Meteorologist Jeff Masters yesterday posted a review of a presentation at the recent American Geophysical Union meeting in San Francisco. The presentation by Shimon Wdowinsky of the University of Miami proposed a plausible mechanism by which the severity of the Haiti earthquake could have been influenced by deforestation and several major hurricanes which affected the country in 2008:
At last week's American Geophysical Union (AGU) meeting last week in San Francisco, Shimon Wdowinsky of the University of Miami proposed a different method whereby unusual strains on the crust might trigger an earthquake. In a talk titled, Triggering of the 2010 Haiti earthquake by hurricanes and possibly deforestation , Wdowinsky studied the stresses on Earth's crust over the epicenter of the mighty January 12, 2010 Haiti earthquake that killed over 200,000 people. This quake was centered in a mountainous area of southwest Haiti that has undergone severe deforestation—over 98% of the trees have been felled on the mountain in recent decades, allowing extreme erosion to occur during Haiti's frequent heavy rainfall events. Since 1975, the erosion rate in these mountains has been 6 mm/year, compared to the typical erosion rate of less than 1 mm/yr in forested tropical mountains. Satellite imagery (Figure 2) reveals that the eroded material has built up significantly in the Leogane Delta to the north of the earthquake's epicenter. In the 2008 hurricane season, four storms--Fay, Gustav, Hanna, and Ike--dumped heavy rains on the impoverished nation. The bare, rugged hillsides let flood waters rampage into large areas of the country, killing over 1,000, destroying 22,702 homes, and damaging another 84,625. About 800,000 people were affected--8% of Haiti's total population. The flood wiped out 70% of Haiti's crops, resulting in dozens of deaths of children due to malnutrition in the months following the storms. Damage was estimated at over $1 billion, the costliest natural disaster in Haitian history. The damage amounted to over 5% of the country's $17 billion GDP, a staggering blow for a nation so poor. Tragically, the hurricanes of 2008 may have set up Haiti for an ever larger disaster. Wdowinsky computed that the amount of mass eroded away from the mountains over the epicenter of the 2010 earthquake was sufficient to cause crustal strains capable of causing a vertically-oriented slippage along a previously unknown fault. This type of motion is quite unusual in this region, as most quakes in Haiti tend to be of the strike-slip variety, where the tectonic plates slide horizontally past each other. The fact that the 2010 Haiti quake occurred along a vertically moving fault lends support to the idea that the slippage was triggered due to mass stripped off the mountains by erosion over the epicenter, combined with the extra weight of the extra sediment deposited in the Leogane Delta clamping down on the northern portion of the fault. Wdowinsky gave two other examples in Taiwan where earthquakes followed several months after the passage of tropical cyclones that dumped heavy rains over mountainous regions. His theory of tropical cyclone-triggered quakes deserves consideration, and provides another excellent reason to curb excessive deforestation!

Original post:
Interesting point of view in today's commentary from Dave Ross on CBS Radio:
. . . I happened to see the AP's annual catalog of disaster and realized that the greatest terrorist of all...isn't some radical bomb-thrower. It's The Planet.

In the year 2010, earthquakes, heat waves, floods, mega-typhoons, blizzards, landslides and droughts killed a quarter of a million people - most of them in January's earthquake in Haiti.

By the AP's calculations, that's more than TWICE the number of people who died in terrorist attacks in the last 25 years, COMBINED. . .

More audio at MyNorthwest.com

This is particularly relevant given the 4 solid pages of prime A-section real estate in today's high-fiber WaPo devoted entirely to analyzing the hundreds of billions being spent annually on "public safety." Apparently we can't afford to spend even a small fraction of that on the much deadlier threat from Momma Nature's attempts to kill us.

Hype-ocracy PM Update


6 PM Update: The afternoon model run is consistent with the morning one in showing a low pressure area tracking to the south of the area and bringing Washington snow on Christmas.

See here for an example of how snowfall amounts are not necessarily correlated with temperatures.

Original post:
The eyeball-hungry low-fiber WaPo has pimped the "s-word" in six seven consecutive [11 pm Update] 8 out of the last 9 blog headlines, but the broadcast media have been maintaining a sensibly low profile on the chances for Washington snow on Christmas. In today's mid-day sample, WRC, Channel 4, veteran Tom Kierein mentioned the possibility of Washington snow on Christmas, but reined in the hype. Even frequent hyper-personality Tom Sater on WUSA, Channel 9, cautiously backed off the assertions last night of newcomer Anny Hong.

The National Weather Service, while carrying a 50% chance of Washington snow on Christmas, is being respectful of the uncertainty at the limits of practical predictability:
LATEST GUIDANCE CONTINUES TO BE IN GOOD AGREEMENT WITH LOW PRESSURE IMPACTING THE REGION SOMETIME FRIDAY AND SATURDAY. THERE STILL REMAINS A GOOD DEAL OF UNCERTAINTY WITH THE TRACK AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE SYSTEM. IF THE LOW TRACKS CLOSER TO THE COAST...SIGNIFICANT SNOW IS POSSIBLE DURING THIS TIME. HOWEVER...IF THE TRACK OF THE LOW REMAINS WELL OFF THE COAST...SNOWFALL WILL BE LIGHT. ALL INTERESTED PARTIES SHOULD DEFINITELY STAY APPRISED OF THE LATEST FORECASTS AS WE GET CLOSER TO THIS POTENTIAL EVENT.
The map to the right shows one major model's interpretation of the surface weather for 7 pm, Saturday, December 25. It has a strengthening storm off the Mid Atlantic coast, with snow over much of the DMV (DC/Maryland/Virginia). If interpreted literally (a serious risk at the range of 5 and a half days), it would generate a total for the event of about 3-5" of snow in the region, with the larger amounts in the southern and eastern portions.

The graph shows snow depth on the ground in Washington on Christmas for each year since 1929. By the way, the 7" last year, while tying the record for the period, had completely disappeared the next day. Note to Ice Ager Linkbot Tom N: If you can find a trend in that data, you deserve to beat out Fred the Singe-r for the Nobel Prize in Cherry Picking.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Hype-ocracy: White Christmas in Washington

In a town normally overrun with hype, the hyping of Washington snow on Christmas reaches even more extreme heights. With the event still 6 days away, the possibility of Washington snow on Christmas has once again appeared among the blogotariat and the ratings-driven media. The chances of Washington snow on Christmas was featured on at least 3 local TV channels (WTTG-5, WJLA-7, and WUSA-9) tonight; WRC-4 was delayed by the football game too late to make this survey.

In fact, this year the cold air is firmly entrenched, but that didn't prevent the earlier outlook for Washington snow [the week before] Christmas to be a complete bust today. Some previous indications of the white stuff for Tuesday have also trended strongly toward the bust-bucket. Nevertheless, some models are hinting at the possibility of a storm developing late in the week and bringing some Washington snow on Christmas.

Three years ago, CapitalClimate surveyed the climatological prospects for Washington snow on Christmas:
Climatologically, there is only about a 10% chance of 1" or more of snow on the ground on Christmas in Washington. Since 1929, there have been only 8 such occurrences. The largest amount was 7" in 1966, with 5" and 4" in 1962 and 1963, respectively. That was the only time it happened in consecutive years. The most recent was 1989, with 2". The wettest was 1.41" of rain in 1945.
Since that time, there has been one more year with Washington snow on Christmas. That was, of course, 2009, when 7" remained on the ground from the 16" which fell on the 18th-19th. That marked the first time there had been Washington snow on Christmas in 20 years. If there is Washington snow on Christmas again this year, it would be only the second time that had occurred in consecutive years since 1929.

As for Washington snow on Christmas resulting from measurable snow falling on the actual day of December 25, that's only happened 6 times in 81 years (7.4%), and only 2 of them were over 1". Here's the complete list:
1962 5.4
1969 4.3
1935 0.6
1970 0.3
1993 0.2
2002 0.2
Still dreaming of Washington snow on Christmas? The odds are certainly better this year than the climatological average, but tonight's glib pronouncement of a "50-50 chance" for Washington snow on Christmas by Washington novice Anny Hong on WUSA, Channel 9, was waaaay premature.

Image (click to enlarge): Washington snow on Christmas (amount falling on December 25) since 1929; CapitalClimate chart from NWS data

Season's Greetings

Greetings of the season, from MIT TechTV's animated snow globe (click arrow below to play; adjust speakers, volume may be loud):

MIT Tech TV

Syracuse Snowfall Smashes Monthly Max


Images (click to enlarge): December 19, 2010, snow depth and departure from normal, from National Weather Service



The 1.4" of snow which fell at Syracuse, NY on Friday, December 17, brought the monthly total so far to 70.9". This is the highest amount ever recorded in December at Syracuse. The old record was 70.3" in 2000. Aided by a persistent northwesterly wind over an unfrozen Lake Ontario, snow has fallen on all but 4 days so far this month. Six inches or more fell on each of 4 consecutive days from the 5th through the 8th, and there have been 3 days with at least 10" each.

With a little less than 2 weeks left, this month is now within 0.1" of tying the 4th highest monthly total in Syracuse history dating back to 1902:
1. 78.1 INCHES JANUARY 2004
2. 72.6 INCHES FEBRUARY 1958
3. 72.2 INCHES JANUARY 1978
4. 71.0 INCHES JANUARY 1966
5. 70.9 INCHES DECEMBER 1ST-18TH, 2010
The latest forecast indicates that the greatest chance for more snowfall in the coming week is a 50% probability of snow showers on Monday.

The December average temperature of 26.2° so far at Syracuse, while 4.4° below average, is not even within 5° of being in the top 5 coldest Decembers. The coldest on record was 14.7° in 1998.

Today's snow depth map for the Northeast from the National Weather Service shows heavy amounts in the lee of the Great Lakes and in the Adirondacks and mountains of northern New England, but little or nothing along the coast and most interior sections.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Arctic Air Attack Registers Records;
Precipitation, Not Temperature, the Real Story

It was noted here recently that heat records have far exceeded cold records in the U.S. for the last 9 consecutive months. Nevertheless, the recent outbreak of Arctic air as far south as the Gulf Coast and Florida has inspired the Ice Agers to Twitch far and wide, "Hundreds of new cold and snow records set in the USA." The heavy snowfall in Minneapolis even led to the collapse of the inflatable roof of the Metrodom [sic].

Is the oft-proclaimed, but never observed, New Ice Age upon us? Well, not quite yet. With the month of December almost half over, the new daily low temperature records have exceeded the new daily highs by a margin of 378 to 191. For the year to date, however, the heat records still exceed the cold records by 7068. At the current rate, the cumulative cold records will catch up to the hot ones in about 491 days, or a little over 16 months.

As usual, focusing on the short term obscures the true picture. Leaving aside the fact that the area of the entire U.S. is less than 2% of the area of the Earth, the latest available December month-to-date average temperature (through the 12th) shows that more of the country is near to above normal than below. Furthermore, the areas with the heaviest snow are not particularly cold.

As was the case with the Mid Atlantic blizzards of last winter, the story here is not temperature, but rather precipitation. The number of daily precipitation records so far in December is 1036, nearly 3 times the number of cold records. On December 1 alone, for example, 334 precipitation records were set, nearly as many as the cold records for the entire month to date. On Sunday, the 12th, the day of the Metrodome collapse, 192 precipitation records were set, vs. only one temperature record. That's right, Jamestown Muni Airport in North Dakota (KJMS) recorded a low of -20°F, surpassing its previous record of -16°F set in 1960. Meanwhile, 13 stations in Minnesota alone were setting daily precipitation records, 5 of them with histories of over 110 years.

Images (click to enlarge): Cumulative excess of daily high temperature vs. low temperature records since Jan. 1, 2010; Total daily temperature and precipitation records Dec. 1-13, 2010; U.S. monthly average temperature departure from normal through Dec. 12. CapitalClimate charts from National Climatic Data Center data, NCEP/NOAA data via ESRL.

Friday, December 10, 2010

Syracuse Snowless String Snapped Sharply

The National Weather Service reports that the 1" of snow which fell at Syracuse, NY on December 3 ended a string of 280 days with less than an inch of snow which began on February 26. This was 7 days less than the record of 287 days from February 26 to December 8 last year.

Since that first snowfall of the season, Syracuse has set 3 consecutive daily snowfall records:
Date    Amount  Old Record Year
Dec. 6 12.2" 8.8" 2000
Dec. 7 9.3" 7.0" 1958
Dec. 8 14.9" 8.9" 1961
Through Dec. 9, measurable snow has now fallen at Syracuse every day this month except for the 2nd. The monthly total so far of 47.7" is over 50% above the average December total of 28.6". On the other hand, this is still well below the top 5 snowiest Decembers since 1950:
1. 70.3  2000
2. 64.6 1989
3. 52.9 2005
4. 52.5 1969
5. 51.9 1970
The December daily snowfall record at Syracuse is 18.6", set on the 30th in 1997. The annual average snowfall is 121.1".

Another extended bout of lake-effect snow is likely next week.

As of last evening, NWS reports show 5-day storm totals approaching 5 feet in a few places:
********************STORM TOTAL SNOWFALL 12/4-12/9/2010****************

LOCATION STORM TOTAL TIME/DATE COMMENTS
SNOWFALL OF
(INCHES) MEASUREMENT


NEW YORK

...BROOME COUNTY...
BINGHAMTON REG 21.7 700 AM 12/9 BINGHAMTON AIRPORT
WHITNEY POINT 16.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.7 SSE
WINDSOR 13.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 8 SE
CHENANGO FORKS 11.1 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3 SE
BINGHAMTON 8.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.8 SW
VESTAL 7.9 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2.8 SSE

...CAYUGA COUNTY...
AUBURN 20.3 1023 AM 12/9 COOP
CAYUGA 16.0 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3.2 ESE
AUBURN 15.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 8.3 SSE
LOCKE 13.3 1029 AM 12/9 COOP

...CHEMUNG COUNTY...
VAN ETTEN 1.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.3 ENE

...CHENANGO COUNTY...
SHERBURNE 28.3 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3.6 NNE
SHERBURNE 16.2 1030 AM 12/9 COOP
NORWICH 8.1 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 5.4 W

...CORTLAND COUNTY...
FREETOWN 15.0 1001 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
MCGRAW 15.0 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 5.2 SE
WILLET 14.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.8 E
MARATHON 13.1 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1 NW
MARATHON 8.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.7 WSW

...DELAWARE COUNTY...
HAMDEN 12.3 1005 AM 12/9 COCORAHS

...MADISON COUNTY...
FENNER 50.6 827 AM 12/9 SPOTTER
CAZENOVIA 48.7 838 AM 12/9 SPOTTER
MORRISVILLE 35.2 1040 AM 12/9 COOP MRRN6
MUNNSVILLE 32.0 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2 SW
LAKEPORT 26.5 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
CAZENOVIA 25.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2.9 SE
EARLVILLE 19.7 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.4 W
CANASTOTA 16.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.9 S
ONEIDA 15.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.7 NNE

...ONEIDA COUNTY...
DURHAMVILLE 17.9 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3.5 NNW
VERNON 17.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.4 NNW
POINT ROCK 15.5 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.6 SE
NEW HARTFORD 10.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.8 S
STOKES CORNER 10.2 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.4 NE
LAKE DELTA 10.1 1031 AM 12/9 COOP
WHITESBORO 8.9 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3.9 NE
ROME 7.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 4.8 SSE
WESTERNVILLE 7.7 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2 NW
WESTMORELAND 7.6 1030 AM 12/9 SPOTTER
HOLLAND PATENT 7.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.5 WSW
BOONVILLE 3.5 1032 AM 12/9 COOP
BOONVILLE 3.3 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 8 E
MARCY 2.0 804 AM 12/9 COCORAHS

...ONONDAGA COUNTY...
DE WITT 58.2 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.4 WSW
SYRACUSE 58.2 1009 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
LIVERPOOL 54.7 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 3.1 N
CLAY 52.1 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 4.6 NW
VILLAGE GREEN 49.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2.6 ESE
SYRACUSE 46.1 500 PM 12/9 SYRACUSE AIRPORT
CAMILLUS 45.2 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1 W
CLAY 44.2 1010 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
FAYETTEVILLE 40.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.6 W
MARCELLUS 36.1 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.6 E
BREWERTON 34.4 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.5 ESE
SYRACUSE 33.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.4 SE
BREWERTON 23.5 1032 AM 12/9 COOP BWTN6
JAMESVILLE 22.3 1012 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
POMPEY 22.3 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 2 NNW
TULLY 17.0 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 1.7 WSW

...OTSEGO COUNTY...
HARTWICK 18.8 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
WORCESTER 18.5 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 4 SSW
COOPERSTOWN 17.6 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.3 S
UNADILLA FORKS 16.8 1014 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
RICHFIELD SPRINGS 13.5 700 AM 12/9 COCORAHS 0.5 ESE
MARYLAND 10.9 1033 AM 12/9 COOP
NEW BERLIN 6.0 900 AM 12/9 COCORAHS
Image (click to enlarge): Clinton Square in downtown Syracuse, Wednesday morning (Dec. 8), from Syracuse Post-Standard.

Seasonal Outlook

Latest seasonal forecast: Click here.


Latest 3-month temperature outlook from Climate Prediction Center/NWS/NOAA.